[JimDabell]

> I think this is the point of disagreement

I appreciate you trying to steel-man their argument, but you’ve gone far enough that it doesn’t reflect what they were actually saying. The thing I’m disagreeing with is:

> Apple's no longer a hardware company

There’s no way to spin that into anything resembling reality. If they had said what you are saying, I wouldn’t have objected.

> my favourite was destroying the business model of their competitors using ATT and then refusing to declare their own ad business ATT compliant

It doesn’t really make sense to do so. Apple aren’t an unseen third-party; the user has explicitly chosen to use their products and services. Why would ATT apply here?

[disgruntledphd2]

Because it's grossly unfair and mendacious to argue that nobody except them should be able to link identities on iOS.

[JimDabell]

They don’t do that as far as I am aware? On two counts. Firstly, they don’t say nobody should be able to link identities, and secondly Apple doesn’t link identities in their ad business.

Just to clarify, ATT is where Apple says that apps can’t collect data on you and share it with other companies without your permission.

When somebody buys and uses an iPhone, they are clearly making an active choice to be an Apple user. Apple can use their data.

When somebody installs a third-party app Foo, they are clearly making an active choice to be a Foo user. Foo can use their data.

But then Foo adds the Facebook SDK to their app. This is invisible to the user. They haven’t made a choice to be a Facebook user. They don’t even know it’s happening. When Facebook gets their data because they use the Foo application, it’s happening without the user’s knowledge or consent.

ATT doesn’t ban Facebook from tracking them, it just says that the user needs to be asked first. It’s putting Facebook’s access to data on the same level of consent as Apple and the apps people choose to use.

Apple using your tracking data in their own ad business doesn’t violate that norm. The data isn’t being sent to an unknown third-party. Apple says:

> The Apple advertising platform does not track you, nor does it buy or share your personal information with other companies.

— https://www.apple.com/sg/privacy/control/

Do you have reason to believe this is a lie? Because if it’s the truth, then Apple are playing by the same rules as everybody else.

[disgruntledphd2]

It's a lie, based on what their sales teams were telling friends of mine who work in the F2P gaming industry.

And they're really not playing by the same rules as everyone else given that they own the platform that all this activity takes place on, so they get basically all iOS users data without needing any permission dialogue.

This is literally part of their ad sales pitch and ads is the fastest growing part of the services business.

So maybe they don't do all this stuff now (but they don't need to because they receive installs and conversions by the very nature of running the platform).

Like, google could make the same claim Apple make here and it would be true for Android.