Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by miki123211 850 days ago
Windows does, it's called Winpe. It's what the Windows installer media runs, but you can (could?) create your own images that boot straight to desktop. Winpe images that included a third-party screen reader were somewhat popular among the blind community at one point, before Narrator (the built-in screen reader) got decent and Microsoft started including it and related components in the installer. I think the original rationale behind this feature was the ability to make custom disks with data recovery tools and such.

Mac OS can boot from external volumes too. It's not a traditional live image, the volume is usually writable and it's a real copy of Mac OS. We're probably talking actual HDD or SSD portable hard drives here, not flash drives, Mac OS isn't that small. You need a Mac to run one of these of course. No idea if this works across computers on Apple Silicon. The new Macs store a lot of the encryption and boot policy stuff in the SE, so I have no idea if booting an unrecognized system would actually work.

2 comments

Not merely the limited functionality of WinPE or WinRE.

It's "Windows-to-Go", introduced in Windows 8.0 which had the full Windows functionality contained on the USB stick, if the bootable stick met the high-performance requirements and had firmware indicating to Windows that the USB stick was not a "Removable Device".

This was gradually deprecated for the most part:

https://learn.microsoft.com/en-us/previous-versions/windows/...

Mac OS used to boot from an HFS filesystem on a CD. I wouldn't be surprised if it could boot from Goddamn anything that could hold it today.