[dunefox]

Can I be sure that Gemini doesn't alter any facts contained in a book I pass it due to Googles identity politics? What if I pass it a "problematic" book? Does it adapt the content? For me, it's completely useless due to this fact.

[curtisblaine]

A good test would be uploading a translation of the Mein Kampf and ask for a detailed summary. Anyone wants to risk their Google account doing this?

[kderbyma]

I think you highlighted the ACTUAL problem....you are worried that Google will destroy your account for harmless tests.....that is plain wrong and should be illegal if somehow it isn't....

[tga_d]

It's extremely rare that you can compel a company to provide a service. The main exceptions are public services (e.g., libraries), utilities (e.g., power), and protected classes (e.g., you can't legally make a business that only serves white people in the US). While I could definitely understand the argument that many tech companies provide services central to our lives and the scope of what is considered a utility today should be vastly expanded, saying this should include access to a particular LLM seems like one hell of a stretch to me.

[mijamo]

I don't think people are worried about losing access to a particular LLM. They are worried about losing access to Gmail, google docs, google photos, their phone, google cloud just because of a test in an unrelated product that happens to share the same account.

[FeepingCreature]

> saying this should include access to a particular LLM

If you get banned from Google, you lose everything.