Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by BuckYeah 846 days ago
NOAA is reporting R3 activity. Solar flare outage seems likely
7 comments

A solar flare targetted at ATT Infra only? Unlikely.

Could be a hack Could be a single point of failure Could be a config change that borked the system

Could be other things that make more sense we will have to wait for more info.

I know the other carriers are saying they aren't affected, but one look at DownDetector shows that nearly every carrier was affected, and all at the same time.
A user who has a working cell phone could contact a user who is on a network experiencing issues. Because the call fails, that user may decide their cell network is also faulty. Downdetector only works on user reports. Its basically useless for actual measurement because people are bad at troubleshooting.
That site counts mentions over social media, if you said 'T-Mobile/Verizon isn't having an outage' it'd still show up as outage activity on it. Plus people report issues calling AT&T customers.
https://www.spaceweatherlive.com/en/news/view/522/20240222-t...

We did have Two Class X flares from sunspot 3590 but they did not result in a coronal mass ejection.

There was a CME from another sunspot not visible but it is not aimed at the earth.

NOAA did release a statement saying the two X class flares were unlikely to effect cellular networks.

https://www.swpc.noaa.gov/news/two-major-solar-flares-effect...

There was an earth directed X class, but not a big one. If that could affect SS7 I would expect it to also take out a chunk of the internet but I am not seeing that. [1] There are many cellular networks having issues but some could be and likely are resellers of others. [2] Probably more likely SS7 related as marcus0x62 mentioned. Another potentially SS7 related possibility? [3]

[1] - https://www.thousandeyes.com/outages/

[2] - https://downdetector.com/

[3] - https://www.webwire.com/ViewPressRel.asp?aId=318230

Then why is this a U.S. only problem?

Edit: I’m getting 1 bar when I usually get 4 in southern Ontario. But I see no broad reports of issues.

Then why isn't Starlink down
Does starlink use the same bands and same equipment? I doubt it
getting BOFH vibes here...
I don't think this is likely