| HN Mirror

Testing Specifically: https://exercism.org/docs/tracks/python/tests

I really enjoyed working with my engineers on this site. A lot has changed since I used it last but the idea being it gives you small bite size challenges to test and exercise testing muscles.

Below turned into a bit of an impassioned rant/soapbox. I still wanted to share in case it offers any support for you on your journey.

You are absolutely right. I spent a good portion of my life testing code on a "line coverage" basis to satisfy management. It was hard to see the value in it when I viewed it as this necessary evil.

I think it is hard because we are often left boiling an ocean of a problem when trying to build software or needing to implement "this thing" before I can do "that thing". Where do I even start? The setup eventually becomes so much that it really brings into question whether it was all worth it.

One thing I can say is, at least for me, TDD was something I had to see done well before I could start doing it. I was never strong enough to understand from an article, book, or video. I paid an expert to pair with me who, himself, got wrapped around the axle trying to implement the simplest of structures.

Ultimately it came down to me working with some folks who had exercised the "muscles" of implementing the practice and had several tools that made the process feasible. Intellij for Java was core, shortcuts, having one side of my screen the test, the other side implementation. Autorunning tests, a simple pipeline that tested, built, etc.

I just needed to see what good looked like to at least start forming an opinion on what was possible for me. Eventually I learned to take smaller and smaller chunks at a time. You want to write an API, sure. Let's just send a {curl equivalent in your preferred language} to this endpoint and get a 200 OK response. Alright, now let's make sure this header is present.

Try not to solve for the future as much as addressing what is in front of you at the moment, or maybe the next couple hours. You'll eventually notice common traits APIs have, database objects have, business logic you care about vs layers that don't belong to you and you can't really control anyway. There will be times that future issues will require you to build certain ways and you just won't know until you've been there a few times.

I learned to approach things with what they called the Triple A Pattern (AAA) and each test had these three blocks of behavior:

Arrange - Create all my objects, initialize, stub out skeletons I've maybe required parameters that I don't actually care about.

Act - Execute my function, catch my object.

Assert - Test that whatever I received is true, equal to "someVal" etc.

There's honestly so much more to say and I glossed over so much. In the beginning I can distinctly remember this existential pain of pulling my repo from git and my environment not running, some cached dependency or browser session breaking things. I constantly felt like I wasn't understanding but I was ultimately learning how much I didn't know about the toolchain, the language itself, the editor I was using and I was finally getting a very clear understanding because I was looking for a very specific response. I started learning how to say, "Based on what I understand, I expect this to happen..." If I'm surprised, then I'm on a new adventure or maybe need to regroup.

I think people believe TDD is supposed to be some panacea but it's only as good as the consistency someone leverages it with. Someone I really respected sold me when they said:

"It just felt nice making some changes and knowing these things I tested for wouldn't pop up again in prod."

That dread of 3am and my name being pulled into a Sev1 call because something was crashing over something simple (and it happened a few times) gave me anxiety constantly. You almost forget how much pressure you feel weighing you down until you leave that team, project, etc. It was a very freeing proposition that had the added bonus of not getting gaslit by people who didn't know what they were saying.

I hope my experience offers some value as I really enjoyed sharing it.