Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by pquki4 858 days ago
Anyone who bothers to distinguish a product from Microsoft/nvidia/meta/someone else already know what they are doing.

Most users don't care whether whether the model is run, online or local. They go to ChatGPT or Bing/Copilot to get answers, as long as they are free. Well, if it becomes a (mandatory) subscription, they are more likely to pay for it rather than figure out how to run a local LLM.

Sounds like you are the one who's not getting the message.

So basically the only people who runs a local LLM are those who are interested enough in this. Any why would brand name matter? What matters is whether a model is good, whether it can run on a specific machine and how fast it is etc, and there are objectives for it. People who run local LLM don't automatically choose Nvidia's product over something just because nvidia is famous.

1 comments

I'll try again.

Have you ever tried to use ChatGPT alone to work with documents? In terms of the free/ready to use product it's very painful. Give it a URL to a PDF (or something) and assuming it can load it (often can't) you can "chat" with it. One document at a time...

This is for the (BIG) world of Nvidia Windows desktop users (most of whom are fanboys who will install anything Nvidia announces that sounds cool) who don't know what an LLM is. They certainly wouldn't know/have the inclination to wander into /r/LocalLLaMA or some place to try to sort through a bunch of random projects with obscure names that are peppered with jargon and references to various models they've also never heard of or know the difference between. Then the next issue is figuring out the RAG aspects, which is an entirely different challenge.

This is a Windows desktop installer that picks one of two models automatically depending on how much VRAM you have, loads them to run on your GPU using one of the fastest engines out there, and then allows you to load your own local content and interact with it in a UI that just pops up after you double-click the installer. It's green and peppered with Nvidia branding everywhere. They love it.

What the Nvidia Windows desktop users will be able to understand is "WOW, look it's using my own GPU for everything according to my process manager. I just made my own ChatGPT and can even chat with my own local documents. Nvidia is amazing!"

> why would brand name matter?

Do you know anything about humans? Brands make a HUGE difference.

> People who run local LLM don't automatically choose Nvidia's product over something just because nvidia is famous.

/r/LocalLLaMA is currently filled with people ranting and raving about this even though it's inferior (other than ease of use and brand halo) to much of the technology that has been discussed there since forever.

Again - humans spend many billions and billions of dollars choosing products that are inferior solely because of the name/brand.