[Yizahi]

Would a single government (for example USA) operating such service be better on average than a single megacorp (for example Match.com)? I think corporate overreach in the democracy is way bigger than government overreach. At least in such simple and inconsequential case.

[whstl]

The problem with Match.com seems to be the fact they do too much (algorithms).

Something non-profit would be able to be better just by having less cash...

The spam problem might be too much, sure, but that also happens in the big apps, so...