[Chris2048]

I don't have access to oed.com - the definition you picked seems to explicitly refer to gender

So, does the word "female" prescribe gender? or not?

Or is the idea that some such definitions might exist, and therefore such words are to be avoided?

On that basis, there are 14 meanings for "pregnant", so how does this not have the same problem?

> If the word red had 24 such distinct meanings

Are the meanings for "female" all distinct?

> As descriptive texts they will always lag behind use in practice

ok, so you are talking about common usage? What else can it "lag behind"?

[AlecSchueler]

I'm no longer sure what you're asking me or what point you're making overall. I understand your individual questions but not what bearing they have to the topic at hand or why I should entertain them.

If you have a point to make then I would rather you simply state it and stand by it. As it is it feels like you're trying to bait me into admitting a fault in my own reasoning using a series of first principle questions. If you see a problem with my logic then please come forward with it, I have neither the time nor the energy to engage in your socratic dialogue.

[Chris2048]

> I'm no longer sure what you're asking

Generally, if it ends with a '?' it's a question. Try answering those, and maybe you'll get the point.

e.g. "So, does the word "female" prescribe gender? or not?"

Why did you choose not to answer that and instead claim you "no longer sure what you're asking"? I'm asking if the word prescribes gender, it's pretty clear!

I also don't have the time or energy - I asked the questions straight, and if I break-down the questions further it's because you didn't answer them in the first place.

> If you see a problem with my logic then please come forward with it

Here's what I wrote, then re-iterated:

>> since in this context "pregnant person" is suggested to be fine, why doesn't the same problem arise there too?

>> On that basis, there are 14 meanings for "pregnant", so how does this not have the same problem?

I'll "simply state it": read what I wrote and respond to it rather than "anticipating" my point and waffling on about something else.

I don't even know what prompted the "Human life has many gray areas" paragraph, it feels like you are responding to something else.

[Chris2048]

Ok, A quick search and it seems you're Irish. I wondered if there was a language barrier here, but it seems that's not the case.

The following definitely needs citation:

"In my country trans men are medically recognised as distinct"