Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by mukundmr 857 days ago
While 28 tonnes appears to be a lot of material for generating 1.2MW of energy, it compares favourably when you look at wind turbines. How often does this need maintenance though?
3 comments

> How often does this need maintenance though?

Moving parts in salt water? Frequently.

The positive thing about this design is that maintenance is potentially much easier than on an seafloor mounted turbine: if the tether is long enough, you can just make the craft surface next to a maintenance vessel with a small crane. No divers necessary, and no giant crane platforms like for offshore wind turbines, either.

> No divers necessary, and no giant crane platforms like for offshore wind turbines, either.

This is critical to the economic viability of the project.

It's certainly one advantage.

I still worry about some of the technical aspects. The craft is going to pull it's own tether through the water behind/"under" it while it "flies" loops in the current at a speed faster than the current itself. That must induce quite a bit of drag, right? Especially because that tether is delivering several megawatts of electric power do the anchor, while holding all the mechanical load of that power being generated. That has to be a beefy cable. And the joints where that cable meets the craft and the anchor are moving parts, for all intents and purposes.

I also wonder how much the craft actually resembles a full submarine. Are there ballast tanks and ballast pumps for altitude control? Full set of diving and directional rudders? What happens when any of those fail?

Potential complexity is certainly higher than for an offshore wind turbine.

> While 28 tonnes appears to be a lot of material for generating 1.2MW of energy

Really? I was thinking the _opposite_; look at the size of hydro and conventional tidal plants.

A 1.5MW on-shore wind turbine (which generates less energy in practice as the wind isn't constant) weighs about 150 tonnes.

Even a 1MW diesel generator weighs about 10 tonnes (obviously not including fuel infrastructure).

Yes I’m envisioning this thing covered in barnacles. Surely they’ve thought of that?