Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by webignition 863 days ago
I'm in the UK, a small town in Wiltshire.

The town I live in is bisected by a MOD railway and, from what I understand, permission was never granted for whatever was needed to supply natural gas on my side of the tracks. This rules out some of the more common traditional heating systems found in these parts.

We bought the house ~two years ago. The building itself was (and still is) quite sound but was a wreck in terms of features (no heating system at all, no flooring at all, and in terms of a kitchen and bathroom facilities it was quite ... minimal).

My partner had long hoped for underfloor heating downstairs as she loves the feel of walking on warm flooring. I have to agree that it is a delightful luxury and we don't otherwise have too many vices.

Direct electric underfloor heating felt like the least hassle in the long term and the easiest for self-installation. The alternative was a wet underfloor heating system (water filled pipework set in screed). The wet system is capable of leaking and eventually failing with expensive repairs, the electric system less so.

We use infrared wall-mounted heaters upstairs. As far as direct electric heaters go they're quite efficient. They heat the objects in the room rather than the air and it feels like the warmth of the sun on your skin.

I agree wholeheartedly that heat pumps are a more efficient option and could indeed be used as a direct replacement for our upstairs wall-mounted heaters. This is something we hope to put in but was not previously affordable when we were re-working the entire of the inside of the house from nothing.

As far as I understand, we would need a wet system for underfloor heating if we were to utilise heat pumps and at this stage that would be a prohibitively expensive re-work of what we already have.

Hopefully roof-mounted solar and a battery of some sort should even out the costs a bit.

2 comments

Thank you for answering!

Yeah there are lots of reasons to not get a heat pump, floor heating is one of them.

And your gp post was not unreasonable, and food for discussion.

But what part for your setup would you replace with GPU heating?

For my setup, absolutely none of it! Wholly incompatible with what I have.

My original question was purely hypothetical and not a practical consideration for me or, probably, anyone else.

> I'm in the UK

I knew it!