Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by hashxyz 867 days ago
AMD will succeed at this as long as they keep it together.
3 comments

Everytime I'm tempted to think software is easy compared to hardware, I just remember that AMD is leaving about a trillion dollars worth of market cap on the table, because they haven't figured out a good alternative to CUDA.
They are definetly putting a lot of effort into ROCm & HIP, but definetly accelerating.

ROCm 6 was out Dec 16 (2023), 5.5 was May (2023). 5 was Feb 10 (2022). 4 was Dec 19 (2020)

Fred Brooks wrote in The Mythical Man-Month that it's harder (more time-consuming) to produce the software that corresponds to a given hardware. In 1975.
Hardware was much simpler and less complex then than now. I wonder how or if that's changed by going from hundreds or thousands of transistors to billions.
They’ll need to either reverse engineer CUDA or incentivize reimplementation of everything out there to use ROCm/OpenCL and forgo all the work load optimization done for Nvidia GPUs. I think that’s a non trivial moat.
This has been my perception of AMD for the past 20 years. First against Intel, then ARM, now NVIDIA. "If only ..."