Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by mrd3v0 870 days ago
Promoting free software through unfree software IS selfish and hurtful to society.

Just because you don't necessarily have a solid counterargument to his convictions, doesn't make anything he said "over the top." That's just a disingenuous dismissive attitude towards what is clearly a post on his personal website that builds on established and clearly communicated values (freedom of software.)

There's absolutely nothing in that article that criticises making and sharing free software. It is clearly criticising using a certain type of medium to share free software. If that's zealotry, then any argument against doing anything is, too.

I wager that this hostility felt by these views are projections of guilt, devoid of criticisms towards said views or values. In fact, I'd argue that having no opposition towards a certain ethos then opposing it for frivolous reasons such as personal offence out of a public blog post is as close to hypocrisy as one can get.

1 comments

> Promoting free software through unfree software IS selfish and hurtful to society.

Well, it's a tough call. I agree that communicating trough them strengthens them because of the network effect. But if you never reach "unaware" people with your ideas where they are (on those platforms, that is), you are not really helping either.

So it's not clear using those platforms only hurts. It could be a net win, all effects taken in account.

In any case, I agree that you should not force people to use these platforms to follow you.