Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by ceejayoz 861 days ago
You have the right to remain silent. You also have the right not to remain silent. Talking after a Miranda warning is taken as a clear waiving of that right to remain silent. You can, of course, stop talking at any time, but they're not going to re-Marandize you after every sentence.
1 comments

That is different that signing something and being held to it.

You waived a right by saying that but you can choose.l to not speak after.

Even if the paper waived an attorney you should be able to change your mind

No signature on paper can force you to keep talking in police custody. You can stop talking at any time, regardless of what you signed.
> No signature on paper can force you to keep talking in police custody. You can stop talking at any time, regardless of what you signed.

Cops are very persuasive when they want to get an answer out of you. Say, they arrest you for whatever, and they can just threaten you to remain in custody for a day... no matter if your pet is alone at home and needs to be fed, or your children need to be picked up from school. Sure, you may call a lawyer to arrange for stuff, but we'll keep your house's keys as evidence...

The freedom to not say anything is utterly depending on circumstances allowing you to do so.

i dont think they can hold you to it, should you change your mind. It isnt binding.