Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by lock-the-spock 861 days ago
Wonderful project, congratulations! I love the speed, clean design, many options, multilingual results, overall very impressive!!

Some quibbles/points to consider: * I can't find anything on the people/organisation behind, and can onl guess from the Terms that the team is based in DK. * Search results are broad and interesting, maybe a bit more weighting for the joint occurrence of terms would be great. * Developing a site weight over time might be interesting, maybe even with user votes. Currently minor and major sites appear all together and e.g. a search for "Donald" gives me an interesting ranking order that gives neither the most famous Donald's nor the most reliable sites firet (not problematic per se - my fault for entering an unclear search term) * There are some interesting result patterns, with often official sites quite low. For instance search for "EU" with some term like subsidy (in any of the languages I speak) gives me random project websites but nothing from any of the official EU websites, or "Microsoft 365" (sorry...) gives me no MS website. * Very minor but hopefully a very easy fix: at least on Firefox mobile there is no direct way to add the search to my search engines, I had to add it manually. For other engines I can long press.on the search field and then get the option.

Great work, keep it up! I will certainly start using this :-)

1 comments

"maybe even with user votes. "

I'm so mind-blown that this does not exist yet. Free ranking feedback (live training of the algo!) + better search results for everyone. win-win

> Free ranking feedback

Free spam SEO ranking in practice. A spam site has 1000x the incentive to upvote its result than you have to downvote it. YaCy did a distributed index with filtering lists and you effectively had to keep a list of who you trust / your own filter.

Kinda solved with accounts, and/or subs, and monitoring/fraud detection? Or just turn it off for product related searches but keep it on for information related?
Have you seen any large site with user reviews? Amazon? Yelp? Any feedback on a page that matters will be gamed, because anything over what you spent to game it is pure profit. This is not a solved issue in any meaningful way.
Paid users only would probably push it in the right direction. It is unfortunate that the internet has moved into everything is advertising as a business model. I get the appeal but cognitively paying so I can keep my attention seems like a way better model.