Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by sandworm101 874 days ago
>>> Farmers with field crops are often beset with Canadian Geese overwintering in the Willamette Valley.

No. I strongly suspect they are dealing with Canada Geese. They are dominant in the photos. Canadian geese would be some random species of geese carrying a Canadian passport. Canada geese are the distinct grey-black species aka cobra chickens.

https://midwesternnewspapers.com/dont-cross-the-dreaded-cana...

2 comments

Not sure why you are being downvoted, this is the best kind of pedanticism.
A large number of people believe it impolite to correct someone's language. I've seen it even called "colonial" to correct written grammar, that we should just let language evolve naturally and not try to enforce rules on others. I am not of that mindset.
I don't think it's obvious that Canadian Goose is any less correct. It's in most dictionaries, and the scientific name "canadensis" is supposed to mean "from Canada", which is what Canadian means. Canada Goose is more common, but that doesn't mean it's better.

It's also pretty likely that the geese in question in this story are literally from Canada.

You should read Power of Babel if you like this topic!

https://www.amazon.com/Power-Babel-Natural-History-Language/...

I am letting language evolve naturally, by providing evolutionary pressure. The people who tell me not to correct people are the ones who don't let language evolve.
Pedantic snark aside, "cobra chicken" is god damned hilarious.