Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by IAmLiterallyAB 881 days ago
Tangently related, does anyone have experience with AsciiDoc? I've used reStructuredText before, but AsciiDoc is tempting, it looks cleaner.
4 comments

Asciidoc has potential. Last time I dug into it the ecosystem was lacking, but there were glimmers of a reboot. I hope that pulls through because it’s a great format.

Edit: yeah it’s managed through the Eclipse Foundation now. They’re slowly working towards a formal spec, haven’t hit 1.0 yet.

Details here https://gitlab.eclipse.org/eclipse/asciidoc-lang/asciidoc-la...

yeah it’s managed through the Eclipse Foundation now. They’re slowly working towards a formal spec, haven’t hit 1.0 yet.

Details here https://gitlab.eclipse.org/eclipse/asciidoc-lang/asciidoc-la...

You have also AsciiDoctor ( https://asciidoctor.org/ ) which is alive and well. I am using it for technical CS documentation internally, but only for single page documents. I did not try to deploy their whole multi-document setup called Antora ( https://antora.org/ ).
I had experience with AsciiDoc and personally not a fan. IMO it has weird features like totally illegible compact table syntax (seriously, that stuff is worse than XML) and the spec looks abandoned. But I keep seeing it being used, I guess it appeals to people who want something more flexible than Markdown (and who like Ruby, or they would go with RST)
Using it for internal docs, but we don’t generate pdfs so I can’t comment on that part.

I personally find asciidoc easier to write manually.