Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by derefr 5156 days ago
> By your logic then if someone gets robbed on the streets, then it's their fault for "walking around freely"?

Well, to more strictly match the analogy--if someone is walking around with a purse that is constantly leaking coins, and they get "robbed" (by someone finding some of said coins and wandering off with them), then I would say that that is their own fault, yes.
2 comments
whackberry 5156 days ago
So by your logic simply owning a Wi-Fi access-point at home and not adding strong cryptography is reason enough for a corporation to drive their car to your house and capture your data?

So to keep Google away from logging my network data I need a strong virtual fence now, otherwise they'll come spying on my traffic?

That is 100% wrong. Google shouldn't be snooping on my data at all, not even if my AP was within their corporate headquarters reach. That is simply not acceptable behavior from a major corporation.

link
magicalist 5156 days ago
No, just like photography being allowed in public does not mean that a video camera is going to be pointed at your house 24 hours a day and you'll be mandated to like it.

On the other hand, the existence of the paparazzi is not enough to justify banning the freedom to take pictures in public places.

All of these laws have to be carefully balanced to make sure we retain our rights.

link
whackberry 5156 days ago
Sure, but what is the parallel here?

The paparazzi make a living from those photos, so there is a reason for them to be out there doing that(not saying I agree, just saying there's a reason for it).

What is Google doing driving around collecting personal data for? Google is a search engine with several great products around it. WTF are they driving around collecting data for? See? It doesn't make any sense, this is plain creepy.

link
derefr 5156 days ago
...because Google Maps has backup-geolocation through a database of wi-fi access point ID/GPS-pair mappings, which can only be discovered by exactly this wardriving process? It's kind of the central point of the story, here.
link
shpoonj 5156 days ago
Thank you for summing this up so eloquently.
link