Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by mewpmewp2 876 days ago
I think odds should be 0.3 to the power of the amount of students.

E.g. teacher picking 1-30 and then each student has 0.3 odds of picking 1-30 or 31-100.

The issue is I think all it would take to beat the teacher is one unusual student.

1 comments

That formula is missing something because for over 100 students the teacher can't lose. (they get over 100 guesses and there are only 100 numbers possible)
More precisely, if there are N students, the probability is (min(N,100)/100)^N. This is 1 for N ≥ 100. And the probability at N=30 is indeed a tiny 2e-16, which shows that the children's "random" picks were far from uniformly random.

(Incidentally, even with N=99 the probability is 0.37 ≈ 1/e, and the probability is lowest at N=37 ≈ 100/e. This is not a coincidence.)

If the teacher does have 100 guesses then they wouldn't lose right.

Then it would be 1 to the power of 100.

I guess I should've clarified that the 0.3 refers to being able to choose 30 out of 100 numbers?