[thomastjeffery]

Then it's the thought experiment that needs re-framing. I'll give it a shot:

At nearly every point in the universe, there is a noise: Cosmic Microwave Background Radiation.

What if you listened to the CMBR at a specific point in space, converted that signal into Unicode text, and it just happened to write Romeo and Juliet? Is that intelligence? No. That's selection bias.

So why is ChatGPT able to quote Shakespeare when asked? Because the entire text of the play is in its training corpus, and the infinite permutations of nonsensical CMBR noise is not.