Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by moron4hire 886 days ago
I hear this a lot and it's difficult to reconcile with my experience. Every US company I've worked at (and that's always been in at-will states) has not made it easy to get rid of people. Even people with woefully bad records of losing money every year and having multiple harassment complaints filed against them were kept for nearly a decade. With one exception (I personally got fired from a tiny startup because I refused to commit timesheet fraud for the CEO), the stories I've heard of the lengths that European companies have to go through to fire someone sound exactly the same to the processes I've seen at all of my employers.
4 comments

You describe a scenario where management didn't want to fire someone - that's why it was harder. In the U.S. only two things get in the way: A) venial corruption B) worrying about unemployment insurance (that's why HR makes you do paperwork documenting an issue).

In many European countries you have to file a ton of paperwork and justify it: ex. at Google, they're still working through _January 2023_ layoffs because you have to work with the government itself and there isn't a good* financial reason for it

* by European standards. "we need stonk to go up" doesn't fly if you're massively profitable

Ive worked at a lot of different earlier stage software companies in the US and we've always fired very quickly, especially if there was harassment, but also just for low performance. Were you working at bigger companies? (aside from the tiny startup where the ceo wanted you to commit fraud) This hasn't been my experience at all.
> Every US company I've worked at (and that's always been in at-will states) has not made it easy to get rid of people.

That's an internal choice they do, to avoid having a reputation of a company that fires people any second (but then you have companies like netflix which take pride in having that reputation, but make up for it by paying more).

However, it's very different from European companies where these processes are (often) driven by laws. In the US there are no employee protection laws (aside from protected classes) so even if the company has a rigorous internal process, they could at any second override it if someone high up says so and you'll be fired in the blink of an eye.

Own a small startup in US. Not hard to fire people. Can do it same day I decide to.