Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by jeffbee 886 days ago
This is not accurate. The policies of the office of the district attorney haven't changed. The SFPD on the other hand has reached all-time-low productivity.
2 comments

Would you mind backing these claims up with the raw data?

Your first claim is DA policies haven't changed, and down-thread you claim "The prosecution rate in SF has been about the same since records began", where are you getting the data to run these reports that support this claim?

Your second claim is: "The SFPD on the other hand has reached all-time-low productivity."

Do you have data to back this claim up as well? if so please share.

You would be unproductive too if 100% of your arrests led to the immediate reslease of the suspect.
The police won their recall election and the Mayor appointed one of their allies as the DA.

Their rates are still abysmal.

The police won their recall election? I wasn't aware that SFPD was sponsoring recalls. And if you're trying to imply the mayor's choice of DA impacted policy, it seems like you should take it up with the person who claims that the DA's policies haven't changed.
I guess if you can name a city where that's true then you'd have a point. The prosecution rate in SF has been about the same since records began.
Prosecution rate is conditioned on the cases presented, so it’s not an independent variable. You can’t infer much from it being constant over time.