| you are making a lot of conclusions that don't follow from your premises and many of your premises are false. "Since Hamas cannot be defeated in this way, it stands to reason"
It can and it doesn't. Of course Hamas can be militarily defeated, its military infrastructure dismantled. "No, they're not, they're just repeating their "but Hamas" stuff"
Yes, they are "What? Name one. What Palestinians actors have talked bout how there are no innocent Israelis?" https://nypost.com/2023/11/01/news/hamas-official-vows-to-re... "Right now, you're saying Isreali is justified in its actions, which is leading to killing and starvation of civilians en masse" This is a war, you can't say Israeli actions are leading to killing of civilians, because this war has two sides, two players. At a minimum, the actions of Hamas have effects on civlians. At the very minimum, misfired rockets that they fire at Israel are known to fall on the heads of civilians injuring and killing them. The war could end if Hamas decicded to end it, not just Israel "IDF soldiers are making their TikToks." IDF has hundreds of thousands of soldiers, so 5 of them made a tiktok, so what? it's irrelevant. |
By destroying civilian infrastructure, targeting journalists, using starvation? No, that can kill all civilians in Gaza, and then there still will be Hamas in a tunnel somewhere.
And that Hamas dude is not an actor? I thought you meant movie actors.
But okay, the only people who say the kind of stuff that is normalized in Israeli society and repeated from highest ranks to lowest soldier, the only equivalent to it, is Hamas. (and probably Antisemites and all sorts of terrible people, but nobody that is remotely considered respectable by anyone in the West). You kind of made that point for me.
> IDF has hundreds of thousands of soldiers, so 5 of them made a tiktok, so what? it's irrelevant.
And when many, many, many of public Israeli figures call all people in Gaza animals and call for extermination, then that's irrelevant because Hamas the terrorist organization is saying terrorist things ^^
At any rate it's not 5, and the fact that they make these genocidal statements while destroying civilian infrastructure, including usually naming their unit, often even the name of the person who leads it, makes it clear that it's not fringe, it's not something hidden, it's not a video that was stolen of a flash card, it's what they upload on social media and get celebrated for at home. And that rhetoric seems to matches the actions on the ground way better than all that stuff about this being "war" and aimed primarily at Hamas.