Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by nerdo 884 days ago
Did they ever explain the logo thing? https://longform.asmartbear.com/logo/
2 comments

> The Smart Bear logo was made by a freelance designer in Austin, TX.

Probably both design teams ripped off the same stock artwork for a bear by tracing it.

That's possible but not likely, IMO.
It is very likely or perhaps they both just googled a bear and traced the same image
Why do you say that? I work in marketing and this stuff happens all of the time.
Because it either would have been wildly popular, and there would be a lot of others, or it would have been easier for Drizzly to to discover from a popular startup blog than from a not so popular stock artwork. Perhaps they could have carried out a search found the stock source as justification for copying it, but that wouldn't have the same story of independent discovery.

Also if you take asmartbear at his word, that sort of implies he at least somewhat believes his designer :) If he didn't think his designer had any scruples about saying that they made that, I don't think he'd have said it so plainly, as "was made by a freelance designer"

> or it would have been easier for Drizzly to to discover from a popular startup blog than from a not so popular stock artwork

It's just a traced vector of a bear. Again, as someone who is familiar with this process, if we were just going to steal something, we would have put a bit of effort into not looking stolen.

Even an amazing designer can't make a silhouette of a bear from memory and he probably didn't take the photo himself. So he surely stole from something else too.

Seems very likely to me.
I'm probably missing context or I'm desensitized by all the blatant copyright violations of the last year, but this is the outline of a bear that, by your link owns admission is not exactly the same, is flipped, has a different color and some text over it. Even if they just took that person's design and modified it is there really something to explain?
And even then my 8 year old could easily create a grizzly silhouette from a photo in 2 minutes. Is this really something to struggle over?