Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by jinpa_zangpo 893 days ago
And prescribed in homeopathy under the name Cicuta Virosa.

(https://plankhomeopathy.com/blog/cicuta-virosa/)

4 comments

Im guessing nobody dies from this, since 30C is water.

The catch is that they’re also without any benefit, and they’re poorer to boot.

With less money to poison themselves with, then. Among those who don't know any better than to buy from homeopaths, that may make the difference.
Nice one.

Homeopathic snake oils are diluted so many times they pretty much guarantee there are no traces of original substance left (they believe the more times it is diluted, the more potent healing powers it gets). I think default is 30 times dilution, each time with ratio 1:100, so you're left with 1e-60 of original, so if you'd put all atoms from milky way (1e68) and start homeopathic them, you'd be left with number of atoms that make ie. a virus (influenza has roughly 1e8 atoms).

I had no knowledge of snake oil terms, so I was confused by the "30C is just water". So after reading your comment, I had to go look it up and came across this [0] with description of the terms. For anyone else ignorant of snake oils ;-)

[0] https://homeosource.org/how-tos-for-homeopathy/what-does-hom...

To be fair, the water used for dilution has orders of magnitude more of stuff already dissolved in it, if only from the person breathing on it.
Surely, you're not implying that someone making a snake oil would be doing so in a non-sterile environment without any kind good manufacturing practices being used. These things seem so trust worthy. I mean, even the government feels they need no regulations because they do it so well themselves.
To be fair, most probably don't actually bother with the original solute, and instead sell straight-up distilled water. Or just tap water.
Well to be fair that’s literally just water…
> Homeopathic medicines are prepared by potentization where the dynamic curative power of the medication is aroused, so homeopathic medicines produce negligible side effects.

Well, that makes me feel better.

Good news, the regular effects are also negligible.
To be fair, most of us tend to be dehydrated, so some beneficial effect is expected