Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by userbinator 887 days ago
If current AI can barely do maths, decompilation is not something I'd expect it to do well. It will of course try and come up with something plausible, but often subtly wrong.
2 comments

gpt4 can spit out accurate unoptimized AST of javascript and python. (I just tried it.)

Now to test emitting.

Would decompilation be closer to arithmetic or translation?
Depends on your goal. If it's matching decompilation, probably the former.

There's been research into the latter but its in early stages. https://github.com/nforest/awesome-decompilation?tab=readme-...

decomp.me gives us a large database of C(++) <-> target asm to train a model on ;)

If you want the decompiled code to produce a 1:1 match with the original binary (even if it takes some finessing by hand at the end) you need something rigorous approaching arithmetic. A fuzzy decompiler that just approximates the intent of the original code won't get you there (and this is mostly what you get out of GPT for many tasks), but it could still be useful for something.