Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by DrScientist 894 days ago
Isn't skin ageing much simpler - the structural proteins in the extracellular matrix like fibronectin get damaged by sunlight over time - crosslinks are formed and the skin loses elasticity?

ie it's not a complex cellular biology thing - just a wear and tear thing, for components that weren't designed to be replaced - ( like adult teeth for example ).

So there might not be an existing biological process you can hijack or reverse - so understanding existing biology might not help you at all.

As to your main point about the complexity of the system. Bottom line biology has evolved to maintain stable patterns - if it was always on a knife edge you'd be dead - so while there might be lots of moving parts the control surface and the state machine has to be much smaller - with the controls being rather forgiving.

As an analogy - you don't need to be a mechanic to be able to drive a car - you can abstract the cars complex mechanics to some very simple high level characteristics - and you can pile those abstractions ( if they don't leak ) on top of each other - so there is a carburettor - you don't need to fully understand how the internals work to understand it's role in the car, but you don't need to know about a carburettor to be able to press the accelerator.

1 comments

> Isn't skin ageing much simpler - the structural proteins in the extracellular matrix like fibronectin get damaged by sunlight over time - crosslinks are formed and the skin loses elasticity?

If that were all there was to it, sunburns you get as a kid will make your skin look permanently older. Barring very severe burns, that doesn't happen. There is however a slower rate of replacement of all sort of proteins and structures as you age. About why it slows down, a biologist will say "the cause it's not well understood". They should instead say "the many causes are not well understood," which is kind of my point.

In this case, there definitely isn't "a" single process to hijack or reverse. The idea of a magical drug is, well, ludicrous. Using your simile, it's like trying to use a car to solve a town's transportation problem. But if increase your complexity budget quite a bit, there are all sort of interventions that will get you where you want.