[idiotsecant]

OK, make the comparison more direct, then. Say you have a filing cabinet with all of your important and \ or embarrassing documents in it. Are you OK with houseguests giving the handle a little wiggle when they come over to check if its locked? What about the neighborhood kids?

[jpc0]

This analogy is more akin to exposing your database to to public internet with no credentials or weak credentials. Thinking about it just like the company in the blog post did... Oh and the filing cabinet is out on the street corner as the other commenter mentioned.

As someone else mentioned this would be more akin to a security officer of some sort waking me up and letting me know I left my front door open. I'd sure as hell be shaken but they were doing their job and I'd be thankful for that.

[filoleg]

> Say you have a filing cabinet with all of your important and \ or embarrassing documents in it. Are you OK with houseguests giving the handle a little wiggle when they come over to check if its locked? What about the neighborhood kids?

If i leave that filing cabinet in the middle of Times Square in Manhattan (which has an insane amount of foot traffic every day), then yes, I would expect plenty of people to give it a little wiggle to check if it’s locked. And I would be rightfully given a lot of questionable looks for complaining that passerbys stop to check it out or give it a wiggle.

Having your service on the internet is not the same as having a filing a cabinet in your house. I think that the Times Square analogy is even underplaying it, given that on the internet, your audience is many many magnitudes larger and more remote/anonymous.

On the other hand, if I had a private VLAN (that wasn’t exposed to the internet) on my home network, then I would be definitely annoyed if my houseguests would try and pentest it without asking.

[prmoustache]

A closer analogy would be your friendly neighbour warning you that you left your garage door open. And yes I would appreciate him telling me.

[jjeaff]

I think a closer analogy would be if your neighbor walked over while you weren't home and lifted on your garage door, noticed it wasn't locked, so went inside and poked around a little. Then came and warned you later that your garage door isn't locked and maybe you shouldn't store those bank statments in the garage.

[troupe]

What if he says that he has discovered that if he stands on one foot in the street in front of your house, holds anyone's garage door opener above his head, and clicks it 25 times at precisely 9:01am while shining a laser pointer at the top of the door, your garage door will open.

[csallen]

I don't think that's a good analogy.

What matters is if the thing they're doing to test your security is similar to what criminals would do to breach your security.

In the case of a physical location, that bar is low. It's things like seeing if your garage door is open, or your car doors are locked, etc.

In the case of computer resources, that bar is high. Probing your database for permissions holes is absolutely something that a normal "cyber criminal" would do. It's the equivalent of a carjacker looking to see if your doors are unlocked.

So an "online neighbor" alerting you that your database is unprotected doesn't feel weird at all. It's not the equivalent of that weird laser pointer thing you talked about, it's the equivalent of looking to see if your car doors are unlocked while you're away on vacation.

[bastawhiz]

Would I be upset at him? No. Would I want to have been told? Yes. Would I think he's a little weird? Yes. Would I want him to keep doing weird shit and letting me know if he finds any other similar issues? Yes.

[prmoustache]

All in all, you will still be thanksfull he found out and warned you about it before someone malicious does.

[oh_sigh]

Still missing something - the garage would have to be on your private property, not visible from public property, and the only way he could check for you is if he entered your property and tried to get into your garage.

[prmoustache]

See my reply above.

[albuic]

On the contrary, I would say that this is a garage you rent on a public space. The internet is open and I can do requests to any server. If you don't want your system to answer me, make sure it does not. If I am in front of an ATM on the public street, it doesn't give me money without authorization. Make sure your server does the same.

[freejazz]

Streets are generally open. My house is on a public street - that doesn't entitle anyone to attempt to operate my garage door, let alone exploit a security vulnerability in its software to gain access. That's just trespassing.

[freejazz]

The closer analogy would be your friendly neighbour warning you that he determined your garage door code was easily guessable after he spent 45 minutes entering different codes.

[wuiheerfoj]

If I left my filing cabinet on the pavement outside my house, I ought to expect it to happen, and would thank a good samaritan telling me if I left it open

[pineaux]

But you would leave it on the pavement right? Little honeypot for nosey punks.