Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by hammock 894 days ago
Why would the duration or frequency of the burst matter if RF is harmless?
2 comments

RF is harmless below the point where it directly heats tissue.

Having a full strength cell tower transmitter inside your home is not safe due to the intensity of the transmission, it will directly heat tissue inside your body.

I think the distinction/point is that it's not harmful in the 'this might give you cancer' way that ionizing radiation sources will. Worst case, you get an RF burn... which is not great, but it's effects are immediate and obvious, unlike ionizing radiation which is much more insidious.
>RF is harmless below the point where it directly heats tissue.

Would it heat tissue anymore than the Sun (in warm places) or your heater or air-conditioner set to heat already does 10x stronger?

Microwave RF that is somewhat directional behaves a lot like laser light.

If you were to step into the beam carried by a waveguide for something like a powerful TV transmitter, it will cook you through like a death ray out of science fiction. Fortunately it's not actually collimated, so just a few feet away the energy is barely enough to cook your retinas faster than your blood supply can cool them (which can cause blindness). Otherwise, yes, it's much like infrared heating effects. If infrared penetrated a few centimetres deep, anyway.

>Microwave RF that is somewhat directional behaves a lot like laser light.

While fob frequency is microwave, isn't it also much lower energy compared to, say a microwave oven, powered by mains power to cook food?

And also the fob operating in the low 100s of Mhz, not GHz, wouldn't that make it less dangerous?

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yqljaKjKjd4

^ this guy literally does nothing more than lay a long wire out on the grass, and touching it instantly smokes and burns his skin

Why would the amount or the way it gets into your body matter if water is harmless?