Unfortunately, I don’t find the acceptance or rejection of a paper in this field has much predictive value these days. By and large, the reviewers tend to be more and more like Wikipedia editors as time goes on.
Whether or not the review process works, open review is a slightly different process. I’d expect a skeptic of the review process to celebrate the idea of reviewers “showing their work.”
Unfortunately, I don’t find the acceptance or rejection of a paper in this field has much predictive value these days. By and large, the reviewers tend to be more and more like Wikipedia editors as time goes on.