[cameronh90]

The point is that, nowadays, apps should by default be isolated from each other, rather than AppData and HKCU being a free-for-all.

Windows makes it hard to whitelist known-safe apps (there’s WDAC but it’s poorly documented and a PITA) and every program you run has access to everything of importance on your system.

Imagine how upset people would be if it turned out TikTok on your phone can access your entire iCloud Drive and Keychain. Yet we accept this security model on our desktops.

[pixl97]

We accept it on the desktop because the desktop app model is from before the internet. There was only 'trusted' applications that had access to all the users data (and really most of the time the entire machine), and really there wasn't even the idea of an internet connection being built in at all. In addition desktop applications are based around the ability to read the users data files. Desktop users typically want all their excel files accessed, along with any embedded images from anywhere in their user directory.

For the most part the changes you'd want to implement for security would ruin the productivity most of the workflows desktop users have these days, and would take a massive amount of refactoring to get to work anywhere close to what they do now.

[lxgr]

There’s a difference between reading user data (i.e. “My Documents”) and reading other apps’ application data (e.g. Firefox’s cookie jar).

macOS has started disallowing the latter (i.e. restricting access to other sandboxed apps’ files from both sandboxed and unsandboxed apps) more than a decade after the OS was introduced, yet I don’t feel like my productivity has been ruined.

[rkagerer]

Older desktop apps also tended to be more trustworthy.

There's so much commodity garbage out there now (e.g. I find it near impossible to find quality ad-free apps on Google Play)