[hattmall]

I think a reasonable analogy would be putting TV's playing porn outside of a school and covered them with a cloth and sign that said adults only. What would my liability be then? And I also sell advertising on the side of the tvs?

[JohnBooty]

    I think a reasonable analogy would be putting 
    TV's playing porn outside of a school and covered 
    them with a cloth and sign that said adults only.

Well, no. Anybody entering or leaving the school would have no choice but to see the covered TVs. Whereas porn is generally not showing up online unless you are looking for it.

Strongly suggest dropping the analogies entirely.

Like many digital concepts this just will never map cleanly to a real-world analogue.

This is like the millions of bad analogies related to music downloads back in the Napster days. Please, stop. This is an issue worth discussing, but every analogy is bad and every analogy pollutes and enshittifies the discussion.

[maxbond]

Though porn advertisements can pop up when you're just minding your own business. The other day a friend of mine was doing perfectly mundane research, and they were shown ads with full nudity. (Yes, I know, they should install an ad blocker, that's not the point.)

That I do think is pretty messed up, and potentially something to pass legislation about. Some people want to opt out of pornography altogether, and their choice should be respected. As should the choice of people who do consume pornography, but aren't choosing to do so at this moment.

[JohnBooty]

I don't know the answer but yeah, I'm definitely on your side about it being a problem.

I saw a bunch of super explicit stuff, unbidden, on my Twitter/X feed the other week and it made me not want to use it any more.

I love porn, but it absolutely should not be shown to me without my consent.

[whatshisface]

Based on the growth of some "romance boutiques," who seem to be able to open chain stores anywhere, the liability is nil.

[hattmall]

They allow kids to go in?

[whatshisface]

To be honest, I don't know - but the billboards are everywhere and not subtle at all.

[itishappy]

No, they check IDs.

Source: Was a kid.