Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by rightbyte 896 days ago
No.

https://www.nilight.com/products/nilight-272pcs-standard-min...

These are not slow burning fuses or whatever. In their product video 6A blows a 5A fuse in like subseconds. However 6/5 rated current should probably blow slower, like days, or not at all? The 2A fuse is probably just made faulty.

Edit: Of course, the Amazon seller could be a counterfeit of "Nilight", which might be a proper brand?

2 comments

Proper brands are not "Nilight" but companies like Vishay, Littelfuse, Eaton, Bel, Bourns, and similar.

Those brands can be found on sites engineers shop on, like Digikey, Mouser, Newark, and similar (which also lets you price / order by the thousands, and feed into manufacturing channels, rather than by boxes of random parts). They will have datasheets, rather than Youtube videos. Better datasheets will often show:

* Typical and worst-case behavior

* I²t, which is used to compute how long it will conduct a given current

* Impact on ambient temperature on rated current

... and similar

Here's a few random fuse data sheets from Mouser:

https://www.mouser.com/datasheet/2/54/SF_1206HH_R-3304051.pd...

https://www.vishay.com/docs/28747/mfuserie.pdf

https://www.eaton.com/content/dam/eaton/products/electronic-...

Some of these are more complete, and some less. That's a fact of life. I can buy a fancy fuse which specs and tests everything for a bit more $$$ for a medical or military application, or one which doesn't for $ for e.g. a toy. If all I'm worried about is a short, that's good enough.

A Youtube video which shows a 5A fuse blowing at 6A means either:

1. The video was baked for Youtube.

2. The fuse will blow at 4A on a hot summer day, running in an even hotter enclosure, and you've bought a bad fuse.

My bet is on #1.

In the line voltage (120v and up) world, fuses are made by Mersen, Littelfuse, and Bussman. Mersen owned Ferraz and Gould-Shawmut and sold fuses as Ferraz-Shawmut until a few years ago when they rebranded to Mersen. Bussman is owned by Eaton, and Littelfuse is an independent company.

Those are the only three manufacturers I ever see specified by electrical engineers in construction specs.