Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by gojomo 905 days ago
Was eager to try but found it buggy - or at least, confusingly arcane in how guesses are scored.

Today's 'transportation' puzzle had 4 consonants & 4 vowels. I got to a guess (nonsense string) whose feedback was 4 vowels correct, 4 consonants correct. (Not sharing here to avoid spoiling for others.)

After becoming frustrated that I couldn't devise a word using those letters, I entered them into online word-finders like those for Scrabble or the Internet Anagram Server – and they're not turning up any single 8-letter word/words (transportation related or not, compound or not) that might be the answer.

Maybe brands? No luck.

Show to wife, she makes suggestion that's similar to the 8 letters I've been trying, but differs in one vowel. Bingo.

So: it was telling me I had 4 vowels correct even when I was supplying a vowel NOT present in the answer.

(A rot13 of a string it erroneously told me had 4 vowels and 4 consonants correct: ZNEBHVYA)

2 comments

When you guess a vowel that's repeated in the answer, it counts all the occurrences.
That makes no sense. Can someone please just tell me the word?
Answer to the first one, written on pastebin to avoid anyone seeing it as a spoiler:

https://pastebin.com/A7RQjNdd

It does make sense. It's just counter intuitive and not the way most puzzle games work.

It makes it quite hard. I'm not sure if it's a good hard or a bad hard yet.

I think you're right - I've updated the rules - give it a go and let me know. Thanks for the feedback.
Thanks so much for this feedback. I think you're right. I've updated the game, and I think it makes more sense now. Please give it a try and let me know.