Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by hw 902 days ago
Great that it works for you and your particular project.

Without knowing the details if your project and team, I’d take a monolith any day over 400 microrepos and the 70+ backend microservices. Our customers don’t care if it’s microservices or monoliths as long as it works and meets SLAs, so the question really is do I want to upgrade ruby or rails 400 times and deploy 100 services or just do it once in my monolith and deploy once?

Need to upgrade a gem that’s used in 100 of those repos to address a CVE - no thanks. Worse, 10 of those repos were owned by someone who left the company a year ago and since there were no PRs, no one knows how to work in the repo or understand what it does.
1 comments
hmeh 902 days ago
That isn't actually the question. I know it's not the question because we're capable of it, it is infrequent, and it takes on the order of single digit person hours a month for that type of concern for our particular project. Also, I didn't say 400 anything but repos. See some of my other comments for what those repos consist of.

> 10 of those repos were owned by someone who left the company a year ago

That's not how it works. Repos aren't "owned" by someone. Each repo stands on its own, is clearly testable on its own. Every one of our teammates is capable of updating every one of our projects because there is consistency between them.

If upgrading Rails or any gem scares you, you have other problems to deal with. For me personally (I'm relatively fast on this team) I can update Rails in all 20 of our Rails applications in maybe 30 minutes unless Rails caused a setback (this is somewhat frequent between propshaft and turbo). If Rails caused a setback, we have two dependencies (rails-application-operational and rails-application-development) that we can either include a patch or pin Rails. All told, it's a quick process.

You know what we don't have to spend time doing? Tracing callbacks across 30 entangled ActiveRecord models. Or anything else that comes from entanglement. We also don't need to entertain palliatives like packwerk and the like.

link