Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by charcircuit 906 days ago
A web browser lets you easily commit copyright infringement by right clicking on a copyrighted image you do not have the rights to and selecting download.

It is also shockingly easy to do.

3 comments

Please, leave my apes out of this.
downloading a copyrighted image is not a crime. downloading and then attempting to distribute that image probably is.
It is not a crime, but in the US you can be sued for $750 to $30000 per unique image downloaded.
I can't understand how people tie themselves into knots with non-equivalent whataboutism when it comes to these correlation black boxes.

The generative "AI" sports out an image it's owners claim is original. That's the infringement.

I would say it depends on the details. The generated image are clearly derivative and not pixel perfect recreations
How many pixels must be the same to qualify as copyright infringement?
Almost no pixels are the same here.

(But neither do the pixels stay the same when you re-compress in JPG. So I'm not sure if Pixel sameness is a good metric?)

That is for a judge to decide probably