[flobosg]

The analysis in the article is very shallow and raises more questions than answers. What motivated the postdoc to fabricate the data? What kind of project were they working on? A postdoctoral position can be a perilous journey, especially if the project involved is a high-risk one (which would be my guess, given the author’s urge to get recognized in her area). If they don’t generate enough data and publications within those few years, a postdoc can leave the lab effectively empty-handed. There is a tremendous pressure for productivity, at all costs.

[shusaku]

It was so shallow that to me it read like an editor took an axe to a shaky draft.