Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by mjburgess 914 days ago
> Shishir Mehrotra (of Coda) wrote about the importance of “Eigenquestions” when framing problems, a term he coined, inspired from his math background:

> the eigenquestion is the question where, if answered, it likely answers the subsequent questions as well.

> This inspired me to name a symmetrical concept I’ve been pondering for a while: Eigensolutions. The eigensolution is a solution that addresses several key use cases, that previously appeared unrelated.

The original article is a complete muddle. It misdescribes framing, and then adds in a misdescription of eigenvectors. It's spending a lot of time and effort on misuse of language to no benefit -- plausibly the motivations were pseudo-intellectual, or at least, intellectually lazy.

The reason it has to do this is obvious: describing breaking problems down, framing problems, and asking fundamental questions isnt new; and no person discussing that seems impressive or a genius.

Throw in a few half-baked borrowed notions from rhetoric and mathematics, however, then it all seems so much more vital.

The whole thing is an exercise in writing 5x as much to say 1/2 of what's needed and playing to a dumb audience ready to lap it up. The dumb audience in both cases are non-tech manager types, who're endlessly desperate to acquire technical language to seem in-the-know.

2 comments

> The whole thing is an exercise in writing 5x as much to say 1/2 of what's needed

That thing right there is what I despise most in non-fiction/non-recreational reading!

A good text says what it wants to say in as few words as possible while remaining easily intelligible to the intended audience.

Clarity & conciseness are the central virtues!

Maybe you could try to be a bit charitable and understand what they meant because I don't think that is so bad.

Of course it could have been said in other, simpler terms perhaps, but that can be attributed to stylistic choices. I'm not too offended by that.

It's rare that people rethink something in terms of (multi) linear algebra, it can be a good reframing for an idea.