Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by jdjdjdjdjd 916 days ago
I see iMessage as simply the default texting app that comes with apple. It can text to any other type of phone and any other phone can text to it. It does have other features/perks that are only available to apple users, but why do android users feel they have the right to this too? It's not like apple only allows iphone to iphone texting.
3 comments

Android users do not want iMessage. What they want is their friends to stop telling them to buy an iPhone because Apple ignores the RCS standard and does a purposely shitty job of integrating SMS group chat into iMessage.

I'm generally pretty laissez faire about technology, but when it comes to things that have achieved high market adoption, I am more sympathetic to the EU's position of enforcing standards.

I have no idea why people support corporations creating these weird little walled garden fiefdoms that are actively user hostile. This seems to be a relatively new phenomenon. Imagine how stupid it would be to have to have an Apple phone to call another Apple user. Or to have to go to a Ford gas station to fill your car. Or if you could only send/receive email with other Gmail users.

No one on Android really cares. It's actually iPhone users either complaining or excluding Android users from group chats.

It's iPhone users creating the social pressure to use iMessage.

I'm an Android user who cares.

Not necessarily for myself, but more generally for the damage Apple is doing to society by creating a divisive wedge between people for the sake of luxury signalling.

Like you say, there are lots of iPhone users who pressure and exclude outsiders to try to force them to get iPhones. Android doesn't do anything like this.

> the damage Apple is doing to society by creating a divisive wedge between people for the sake of luxury signalling.

Would you be able to elaborate on this and provide some examples, please. With respect to iMessage, that is.

Some people are apparently so torn up about their text message bubbles being a different colour, they’ll apparently wage a holy war for it in the comments.

Spoiler alert everyone: if you want the product feature, buy the product.

> It's not like apple only allows iphone to iphone texting.

Because of the limitations of SMS (not supporting high res pictures, no groupchats over 10 people, etc) it effectively is only for iphones. People with Android phones in the US in iPhone-circles simply cannot be socially integrated and have full social lives