[james-revisoai]

Good points... In many ways, before LLMs, vectors were getting so exciting, Sentence Transformers and BERT embeddings felt so instrumental, so powerful... work by the txtai author (especially things like semantic walking) felt incredible and like the next evolution. It's a shame in a way that all the creative and brilliant uses of text embeddings from similarity embeddings didn't really have any time to shine or go into product before ChatGPT made so much except search use cases obsolete..

[Der_Einzige]

Btw - I published a paper at EMNLP with the txtai author (David) about using semantic graphs for automatic creation of debate cases!

https://aclanthology.org/2023.newsum-1.10/

Happy to see that David's excellent work is getting the love that it deserves!

[dmezzetti]

Thanks for the nice words on txtai. There have been times this year I've thought about an alternate 2023 where the focus wasn't LLMs and RAG.

ChatGPT certainly set the tone for the year. Though I will say you haven't heard the last of semantic graphs, semantic paths and some of that work that did happen in late 2022 right before ChatGPT. A bit of a detour? Yes. Perhaps the combination is something that will lead to features even more interesting - time will tell.

[charcircuit]

>It's a shame in a way that all the creative and brilliant uses of text embeddings from similarity embeddings didn't really have any time to shine or go into product before ChatGPT

Yes, it did. Companies that offer competitive search or recommendation feeds were all using these text models in production.

[james-revisoai]

I was running one of them, and entering kaggle competitions throughout 2021 and 2022 using them. Many efforts and uses of Sentence-transformers (and new PhD projects) were thrown in the trash with Instruct GPT models and ChatGPT. I mean it's like developing a much better bicycle (lets say an ebike) but then cars come out. It was like that.

The future looked incredibly creative with cross-encoders, things like semantic paths, using the latent space to classify - everything was exciting. A all-in-one LLM that eclipsed embeddings on all but speed for these things was a bit of a kill joy.

Companies that changed existing indexing to use sentence transformers aren't exactly innovating; that process happened once or twice a decade for the last few decades. This was parents point I believe, in a way. And tbh, the improvement in results has never been noticeable to me; exact match is actually 90% of the solution to retrieval(maybe not search) already - we just take it for granted because we are so used to it.

I fully believe in a world without GPT-3, HN demos would be full of sentence transformer and other cool technology being used for demos and in creative ways, compared to how rarely you see them.

[Der_Einzige]

Also, people seem to have forgotten that the whole technique behind sentence transformers (pooling embeddings) works as a form of "medium term" memory in-between "long term" (vectorDB retrieval) and "short term" (the prompt).

You can compress a large N number of token embeddings into a smaller N number of token embeddings with some loss of information using pooling techniques like what was in sentence transformers.

But I've literally gotten into fights here on HN with people who claimed that "if this was so easy people would be doing it" and other BS. The reality is that LLMs and embedding techniques are still massively undetooled. For another example, why can't I average pool tokens in ChatGPT, such that I could ask "What is the definition of {apple|orange}". This is notably easy to do in Stable Diffusion land and also even works in LLMs - despite that even "greats" in our field will go and fight me in the comments when I post this[1] again and again, desperately trying to get a properly good programmer to implement it for production use cases...

[1] https://gist.github.com/Hellisotherpeople/45c619ee22aac6865c...

[wahnfrieden]

Share use cases?

[charcircuit]

>Many efforts and uses of Sentence-transformers (and new PhD projects) were thrown in the trash with Instruct GPT models and ChatGPT.

There still exists a need for fast and cheap models where LLMs do not make sense.