Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by PrimeMcFly 911 days ago
> How is iMessage a monopoly? I would like open communications standards as much as the next guy, but next to iMessage there are WhatsApp, Telegram, Signal, WeChat, Facebook Messenger etc. etc.

Because it's the replacement for SMS for Apple phones and doesn't require an account in the same way those other services do. It just uses the Apple account iPhone owners already need to have.
1 comments
frumper 911 days ago
You don't actually need an account to use an iPhone. You can also use SMS without iMessage.
link
PrimeMcFly 911 days ago
> You don't actually need an account to use an iPhone.

Really? It's never insisted upon for any core service?

> You can also use SMS without iMessage.

But most people don't because it's the default. MS was found to have a monopoly with IE even though there were alternatives.

link
joshmanders 910 days ago
> But most people don't because it's the default. MS was found to have a monopoly with IE even though there were alternatives.

Windows also was the dominant operating system with a market share in the 90% or higher. iOS isn't even the market leader in the US let alone the world, so can't really be a monopoly now can it?

link
dwallin 910 days ago
54% of the US market makes them a pretty clear market leader. https://www.statista.com/statistics/266572/market-share-held...
link
PrimeMcFly 910 days ago
> iOS isn't even the market leader in the US

How can that not be true if most people in the US use an iPhone as their phone?

link
joshmanders 910 days ago
iPhone and Samsung combined make up almost 80% of smart phone market share in the US. Being as Statistia is a premium thing I can't get accurate numbers, but lets say splitting 50/50 because if it was anything with any serious gap, they wouldn't group them the same. I'd assume they're high 40's and low 50's split between the two, so means iPhone is ~40%, now I ain't no math magician or anything but that leaves ~60% for non-iPhone devices.
link
PrimeMcFly 910 days ago
In plenty of other threads I've seen people bring up that in the US most phones are iPhones, they are the most popular choice by far. I can't remember where they sourced the info from and not about to research it myself though, at least not at the moment.
link
averageRoyalty 910 days ago
> Really? It's never insisted upon for any core service?

You might need to qualify "core service" here, but no. Calls, SMS, MMS, internet all work fine without an account. You need an account to download apps from the app store, but that's a different argument. If you wanted to, there are various methods to load apps up without an account too (side loading via Xcode, MDM, etc).

link