Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by vouaobrasil 924 days ago
There is no such thing as a 'just a tool', because we have fundamnetal and basal instincts that cannot be stopped when we operate in a large group. Tools always interact with these basal instincts in predictable ways that cannot be stopped within our modern technological society that has an incredible amount of inertia.

To say that anyhting is 'just a tool' is exceptionally naive and only works in small group settings.

We will never find people who govern fairly or corporate leaders who refuse to priortise profit as long as we maintain and support a system that is conducive to their growth, just as we will never stop the growth of bacteria in a bacteria-rich medium.

Yes, a hammer can be used for good or bad, but it will always inevitably be used for bad in an environment that encourages such uses.

2 comments

> There is no such thing as a 'just a tool', because we have fundamnetal and basal instincts that cannot be stopped when we operate in a large group.

Empirically that seems to be true.

> Yes, a hammer can be used for good or bad, but it will always inevitably be used for bad in an environment that encourages such uses.

From your previous line that I quoted, that would be any environment that has humans in large groups. Now what do you propose? Short of returning to hunter-gatherers (with the death of about 7.9 billion people), I don't see how you're going to prevent that kind of environment.

That’s why I wrote “But why would this technology be any different to prior new technologies…”

We don’t have the environment to change it