Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by SoftTalker 917 days ago
There are other, sometimes contradictory conventions.

In the USA, a standard wall switch is moved "up" for on and "down" for off whereas in Europe it's the opposite. Always wondered how that came to be.

2 comments

Then there's standard walls switch in Europe, which works whichever way the electrician happened to wire it. And then, existence of "stair switches"[0] means you can't ever rely on directionality being consistent.

Now, let's talk about water faucets and which side is hot, and which one is cold...

--

[0] - Don't know what the formal way for these are; I'm thinking of two switches hooked up in a XOR pattern to the same light - i.e. light turns on when the switches are in opposite positions, and off if they're in the same position.

> Don't know what the formal way for these are

These are called "three-way switches" in the US.

Oddly named, as they only have two switches in the circuit.
They're called "three-way" because there are three elements to the circuits they're used in: two switches and a load.

...or so I was taught, but that explanation always seemed a little dubious to me.

I thought three-way was for three possible states: up/down, down/up, or down/down(up/up). Switch 1 up, switch 2 down, etc.
(US here) -- I remember to install light switches so that the up position is "on" because of a faulty light switch I had decades ago -- the spring holding the position was broken so that, over time, gravity would eventually make it fall to the lower position.

Having the lower position be "off" seems like a good failsafe for that sort of thing. I don't know if that's why the convention, but it is the mechanism that I use to remember what the convention is.