Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by ur-whale 927 days ago
OpenSource working as intended, no?
4 comments

Just because a system works doesn’t mean all outcomes out of the system when it’s working are equally good.

Even the best working system will still require people to make good decisions to have the best outcomes.

Sure, in the sense that they can differ and co-exist? Of course it's much better in OSS when differences can be resolved so that more people may work together on fewer forks, so discussion should come before forks most of the time. The author seems to be doing exactly the right thing - tried to contribute to the shared work, voice their concerns and thought process, and ultimately fork in protest.
Absolutely not! Free Software working as intended. Are you trying to trigger RMS by calling Emacs "Open Source"?
Yup. Great isn't it when the system works as intended.