Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by bequanna 925 days ago
How in the world would more regulation around who can fix a piece of broken trim board help at all?

We should be thankful the US doesn’t have a system like that which artificially reduces the supply of labor.

We should make it easier for people to work in the trades. Not wrap and bunch of unnecessary formality and regulation around it.
1 comments
georgeoliver 925 days ago
It doesn't seem to reduce the supply of labor in Canada, since the author of the article is self-taught.

However it's likely to increase the overall level of training, which is good for someone who needs their broken trim board replaced.

link
notyofriend 925 days ago
No it’s not good. The lower the barrier to every the better. More ability to choose the level of quality work you desire. A handyman for bill gates is going to be a complete different class than one for the roach motel but it’s still good if the roach motel can get one.
link
leipert 925 days ago
Mhm. Here in Germany plumber, electrician, etc. are all “protected” jobs. You can’t call yourself a plumber or electrician if you haven’t learned the proper trade. I’d argue it’s good for safety, standards and liability.

Now when it comes to stuff like building a kitchen, you could go with proper carpenters or furniture folks or a handyman. It’s good to have those different categories and know what you would be getting.

link
JoBrad 925 days ago
That’s sort of true in the US, as well. A plumber or electrician is licensed, but handymen aren’t, as far as I know.
link
notyofriend 924 days ago
Germany takes it too far. Every industry is regulated and licensed. It takes 2 years to call yourself a baker. It’s not a good system.

If you have to regulate industries institute a proficiency test and allow different levels of expertise. A plumber or electrician for home repair is a totally different level of complexity to one in industrial applications but it’s the same certification. The guy doing wiring in my house just does not need that level of education and I don’t really want to pay for it.

link
bequanna 925 days ago
It's essentially the same in the US.

If there is a large risk when work is low quality, there is regulation. The more possible danger, the more regulation. This is OK.

But an argument for regulation that is just some hand waving and repeating "standards" is not a legitimate position. It is an attempt to build some little bureaucratic empire which will enrich a group via regulatory capture.

The government wins as they now have more employees and more power and the people already in the trade win. Everyone else loses.

link
bequanna 925 days ago
I’m not some free market purist but in this situation we absolutely do not need more government regulation and the risk of low quality work is quite low.

A typical handyman can’t and won’t touch anything that could actually cause harm (gas, plumbing, electrical) and poor quality work will result in a negative reviews and no repeat work for the handyman.

More opportunities for training and upskilling, yes!

But you should not start some unnecessary credentialing/licensing system that restricts the supply.

link