Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by tptacek 919 days ago
You don't really need to understand elliptic curves to understand Dual EC. It's a public key RNG. The vulnerability is that there's a matching private key.
1 comments

True, but my parenthetical was covering the opposite issue: it's possible to not realise DUAL_EC_DRBG is broken (rather than impossible to realise it) if your only knowledge of cryptography is, say, hash functions and stream ciphers (so you don't recognise public key cryptography from looking at it). It's unlikely, because DUAL_EC_DRBG is really obviously broken, but I wouldn't fault someone who knew nothing about elliptic-curve cryptography for missing it, even if they were familiar with other types of cryptography. (I would fault them for claiming that it's secure, rather than recognizing that they don't know enough to evaluate its security, but you can't conclude something's backdoored just from that.)