Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by DiggyJohnson 923 days ago
Is this a serious proposal or am I missing how this is a joke?
3 comments

This person has never seriously considered a public policy solution and they are still learning what is and isn't going to scale.
I still don't see what is wrong, it prevents congestion, it is fair and equal for everyone. And if they can charge based on license number, it is no more difficult to implement.

Isn't the goal here to have less cars in the zone? Thus goal is preventing them from entering. And giving everyone equal chance to win right of entry is fairest model.

But then you would completely lose the ability to plan ahead. You would not know how you were going to travel until the lottery results.
Shooting and killing a random 1% of drivers every day would also prevent congestion, and is fair and equal to everyone. There are other considerations though.
China has an odd-even solution to this - on even days, cars with even numbered plates can drive in the city and the same for odd days. They did this for gasoline rationing in the US back in the 70's as well.
This would be marginally good for automakers. Some people would decide to buy an extra car to have on-going access.