Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by k8svet 919 days ago
What exactly were TETRA radios used for? I assume they were government/infra related, but then I don't understand why they'd need to backdoor the keying
4 comments

They are used for many things, like fire, ambulance, railways, harbour operations, police, military, coast guard, and so on.

The weaker cipher mode, TEA1, is used when selling the radios to anyone who may not necessarily be an ally or highly trusted. This is the legacy of strong crypto being export-controlled.

It was public that these ciphers were weaker, but they were actually much weaker than advertised. This is the backdoor.

They don't so much backdoor the keying as that they have 4 different cipher profiles, and the one approved for global rather than European use (TEA1) compresses the key from 80 to 32 bits.

It's essentially a surreptitious version of what the US did in the 1990s with "export ciphers".

Which makes me question describing this as a "deliberate backdoor."
It's pretty clearly a deliberate backdoor.
And that is supported by the known past actions of "some government authorities". This is definitely not the first time the US government has deliberately sabotaged crypto.
This isn't an American product.
It's deliberate in making the crypto so weak that our guys can decrypt their guys' radio traffic.

How's that not a backdoor?

I think the most relevant use in the context of deliberate backdoor is its use by police and military forces. Apparently some energy providers also use it for remote controlling tasks (no voice).
There was also the Dolphin network in the UK, offering a public national subscription TETRA network. It didn't prove commercially viable.

https://www.rcrwireless.com/19980309/archived-articles/dolph...