Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by solardev 930 days ago
AVIF and WebP, two modern replacements for both JPEG and GIF on the web, both support lossy and lossless encoding.

WebP is mature and has more browser support, but AVIF is getting there (notably only lacking Edge support). Both can compress in either a lossy JPEG-like fashion or in a lossless PNG-like fashion.

If you use a image CDN like Imgix, it'll just auto-detect and serve whatever the most optimal format is anyway: https://docs.imgix.com/apis/rendering/auto/auto#format. Cloudinary too: https://cloudinary.com/documentation/image_optimization#how_...

For non-web, there's also JPEG XL to look at, but if you're not doing rendering an image for redistribution, it's probably better to keep it as raw as possible anyway (i.e. camera raw images plus photoshop layers, or whatever).
2 comments
ComputerGuru 929 days ago
WebP and AVIIF (and, to a much lesser extent, HEIC, which AVIF is basically a rip off of) absolutely suck for color management since they are a) virtually never original source formats, b) are video codecs. WebP technically supports two different color profile techniques (traditional embedded ICC - broken in every mainstream batch image processor I’ve tried - and nlx video-based color profiles). Unlike WebP and all the other image formats, untagged AVIF can’t be assumed to be sRGB (in part because there is no actual sRGB for video, though close variants exist) and every image processor or image editor will open it with a different base color profile assigned. WebP doesn’t even support exif, making it absolutely horrible for “lossless” operations that effectively aren’t lossless since they necessarily destroy metadata.

HEIC is also a video codec at heart but has a default color space that also isn’t sRGB (which is a good thing; it’s about time we moved on), untagged HEIC images can (though often aren’t in any default workflow) be assigned Display P3. Assigning/assuming sRGB will absolutely break your images, of course.

link
eyegor 929 days ago
The worst part about avif support in edge is it was added as an optional feature flag ~8 months ago but it still isn't enabled as a default. Nearly every other browser supports avif by default these days.

https://winaero.com/avif-support-is-now-available-in-microso...

link