Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by igiveup 915 days ago
Human laws do not follow laws of nature, or laws of logic. Trying to rationalize why something is or isn't owning or stealing is a misunderstanding.

"It is not missing anywhere, so it isn't stealing" does not apply. What applies is more like "This paper says it is stealing, so it is." The paper says it because a human wrote it there, as a result of whatever complexity going on in their natural neural network.

Please notice I didn't say "right", "wrong", "good", or "bad" anywhere.

1 comments

We write these laws on paper, and not on two stone tablets because they aren't fixed.

You make it sound like "once it's written down, that's how it is. forever". Which is also not how law works (not even how religious "laws" work).

To me, it sounds more like you're saying the same thing as me: It is not a law of nature, it is text on paper, a human fiction. Yet, somehow you manage to disagree with me. How did that happen?