Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by jsomedon 921 days ago
I've played dos and dos2 and I liked them(well I enjoyed dos's combat system more than dos2 but I loved playing them both in general), I've never played any DnD games, should I buy bg3?
3 comments

Bg3 is pretty much DoS2 in a different skin. And a different story/universe.

If you've played DoS2 you'll find yourself sometimes conflating the two quest lines sometimes :).

I haven't played DOS (though now I might). My understanding is that BG3 is more story and character focused. And while they've done a surprisingly good job adapting D&D combat to video game format, it's definitely not perfect.

I definitely recommend it

Yes. It’s fundamentally the same game, just with combat rules that aren’t quite as good. It feels very much like DOS:3.
The plot is a bunch more engaging, to me at least. Divinity always felt you were playing everything for laughs.

D&D is a crap system though, which drags BG3 down (but hey, I've made my peace with D&D's vancian magic at this point in my life).

Did you play DOS:2? I get that sentiment for DOS:1, but 2 took things more seriously.
Yeah, almost all of it (level 14 or so). I felt the tone was super light-hearted, which was fine but I was concerned that BG3 might be similar. Fortunately, it's not it has a more appropriate tone.

To be fair though, we had our second child in September, so I'm just at the end of Act One (hoping to get some time to finish it over Christmas).